Blog Image

International Network Observatory

Global Strategy and Big Data

Humanising Online Pedagogy‌: on data and education

Innovation Posted on 02 May, 2014 09:49

Humanising Online Pedagogy‌
Friday 23rd May 2014

The Arbour Room, Hope Park, Liverpool Hope University‌

For many of us the digital age seems to have long since arrived. Yet our social, cultural and particularly our educational institutions are struggling to adapt. There are a range of practical and philosophical issues at stake. Practical considerations include how to engage students with truly blended learning, and how inclusive technological mediations and interventions can be. But such practical concerns are themselves predicated upon deeper questions about the nature of knowledge in the digital age, and whether physical presence is an inalienable aspect of pedagogy.

This one-day workshop will provide a showcase for recent work undertakenby the Philosophy of Educational Technology group at Liverpool Hope University, while also drawing together other partners interested and involved in this conversation.

Funded by BERA (British Educational Research Association), PESGB (Philosophy of Education Society of Great Britain), and hosted by Liverpool Hope University, this event will support the wider discussion of Philosophy of Technology as it relates to pedagogy.

‌If you would like to book a place on this one day workshop, please visit the Hope Online Store to register your place.

‘How the Internet defeated Seymour Hersh’

Innovation Posted on 02 May, 2014 09:38

Seymour Hersh, the Pulitzer Prize winning investigative reporter, has re-opened the discussion on who was behind the Chemical Weapons attack in Syria. Hersh argues that Turkey supplied the rebels with these deadly weapons in a ‘false flag operation’ designed to create the legitimisation for military intervention.

At first sight, this looks like exciting investigative reporting by an icon of free journalism. A closer look, however, reveals the work of a twentieth century reporter whose methodology has become heavily outdated and perhaps even unreliable. Hersh’s story is based on a single anonymous source – rumoured to be F. Michael Maloof, a former George W. Bush Defence staffer.

On the other side of the debate we find the likes of Eliot Higgins who runs theBrown Moses Blog. Higgins has no qualifications in Journalism or Foreign Policy and has never set foot in Syria. But he understands the internet’s defining characteristics and turns it into a strategic advantage to gather information and, as such, is able to successfully challenge the grand master of investigative journalism.

By cleverly utilising the network characteristic of Twitter and by gathering the infinite images emerging from the deadly conflict via YouTube and Facebook, he manages to document the dynamics of the conflict in detail. This methodology has turned his blog into a credible source of information referenced by traditional media outlets like BBC, Reuters and CNN.

Higgins represents two distinct features of the information age: ‘open source’ intelligence gathering and unfamiliar networked solutions, developments that Hersh has ignored but which are radically changing the fields of intelligence and journalism.

Both intelligence analysts and journalists heavily relied on a handful of sources to create stories. Verifying for reliability of the source and keeping the identity anonymous was part of best practices in both fields.

The emergence of the digital age has fundamentally changed this. As social media are datafying social life, relationships, behaviour, thoughts, locations, and networks, a vast amount of messy data is suddenly available to be harvested. Most of this data is open source and can be accessed by individuals such as ‘Brown Moses’.

In the aftermath of the Ghouta attack on the 21st of August last year, the Leicester-based blogger started analysing the videos on YouTube and information on other social networks. Much of the data was in Arabic, a language Higgins does not understand, and thus had to rely on Google Translate and support from his followers.

It took Higgins several months to reconstruct that the type of rocket (‘Volcano’) used in the attack has indeed been used before and, moreover, that the Syrian Arab Army and the Syrian National Defence Force has this specific type of weapon in their arsenal. Furthermore, his work revealed how the missiles were fired from regime-controlled areas.

Seymour Hersh on the other hand chose to ignore this publically available information that was contradicting his argument and instead relied solely on a single source. His methodology certainly proved useful in the Cold War as evident from his work on revealing the My Lai massacre, for instance.

‘The Internet’ has rendered the work of one of the world’s most famous reporters severely outdated and even unreliable. A social media-savvy nobody from a medium-sized English town with a good online network is beating the grand master in his own game.

Hersh’s article is a welcome addition for those seeking to uncover who was behind the attack that killed over a 1,000 civilians and nearly caused a US-led military intervention in Syria – if only for putting it back on the agenda. But moreover, it signifies a fundamental change for the intelligence community and news media that times have changed and innovative, networked, and open sourced approaches are vital for reliable information gathering and analysis.

This entry by Anno Bunnik, PhD Fellow and Coordinator at CASI, was first published on openDemocracy and Anno’s blog